An aunt of mine visited us recently from afar as she had to attend a
wedding of her friend’s daughter in our city. She insisted that i and my wife
also join her in the ceremony as the invitation was for her “With Family”. We
were reluctant; she was persuasive.
In deference to her elderly command, the fragile structures of our diffidence
towards being an uninvited guest were caving in. As she showed us the
invitation card for the address, a line at the bottom caught my attention and
the decision was made.
We decided to accompany her. The footnote in the card – “No gift, no shagun1, only blessings”
emphatically declared the magnanimity of the host. The residual resistance
disappeared.
Having grown through times when shagun
or gifts were a must in weddings, I was indeed amazed at this subscript but was
carried away in my newfound respect towards the host. It reinforced my belief
that the society is shedding inhibitions. Live-in relations, surrogacy, funky
dressing, flexi and 24*7 working, selfie-mania, freedoms of midnight,
sub-nuclear families – all are symptoms of a flux that is gradually settling in
our eternally fertile cultural soil. The Aryans, the Mughals, the British – all
separated by a few hundred years each - left their imprints in one form or the
other on us and our identities evolved. Now, with the instant exchange of
information globally, the evolution is taking shape of a revolution, much shrunk
on the timescale. Transparency is now the buzzword and the evolved souls – like
the host above - apparently are no longer bothered about what the world will
say on questions of credence such as what do i do? whom do i live with? what
time do i come home? and so on.
Great! Thoughtful time though!
Was this enough provocation to write an obituary on hypocricy, I mused?
While Trump is blowing the trumpet of transparency, back home, instances of ambiguous
statements by one and revelations of reality by another are making the
headlines. With increasing focus on self, individuals may be becoming more
courageous and truthful – even to the extent of accepting in public the
hitherto taboo aspects such as LGBT – collectively, the mindset continues to
remain masked in the mire of worldly exhibitions. Today’s host was one such brave and unorthodox individual, unmindful of what the world would say on his statement
in the invitation card. Kudos! More such people can certainly remove the veils of duplicity from around us and fuel the revolution.
Enjoying some sumptuous preparations, I spotted a grin on my wife’s
face.
“Are not finding anything tasty?” I asked
“No. I am not feeling comfortable because we are uninvited”
Was she another epitome of transparency in the evolving society, I
wondered. I quickly swallowed the piece of nicely done paneer tikka2 and stood by her trying to understand her.
“I insist that we should part with some shagun as our good wishes for the new couple”, she said.
I listened, patiently as ever, and wished If only she could focus on
food!
The host was candid in declaring “no gifts..” whereas the uninvited guest
(my wife) was insistent on shagun – both
were true to themselves – each perhaps subscribing to a different frame of
reference. But whom do i incline with? My mind was in a muddle.
A friend appeared from behind and as we exchanged pleasantries, he took
excuse from my wife and pulled me to my much awaited next round of culinary
delight.
A few snacks later, i saw my wife coming towards me and I quickly ran
through the remnants in my plate. Surprisingly, she had a sparkling smile on
her. She seemed to have overcome the archaic mindset and fallen in sync with
the transparent times.
I presumed that the maze was solved. I was relieved.
“I went with aunt and handed over a shagun
envelope to the host, who gratefully acknowledged” she announced; “Did you
taste the chilli mushroom? They are just amazing” she added after a pause.
I was mute. The maze was not solved; on the contrary, it left me amazed
and bisected. Even the publicly written words did not stand ground. The masks
of mankind were yet to be fully uncovered. While my wife enjoyed the meals that
followed, I nibbled at the nuances of transparency.
My thoughts on obituary of hypocricy seemed to be pre-mature.
Wondering…
1.
Shagun
– In some parts of the country, guests shower blessings by handing over some
currency in attractive envelopes to the hosts during ceremonies such as
wedding.
2.
Paneer
Tikka – an Indian delicacy of oven - grilled cottage cheese
And that is why it is so truly said that it is right to go with the flow of world.....duniya ke dastoor ke saath hi chalo...
ReplyDeleteAnd that is why it is so truly said that it is right to go with the flow of world.....duniya ke dastoor ke saath hi chalo...
ReplyDeleteIf that be so, then who will hold the baton for bringing a change
DeleteI wouldn't consider it hypocrisy -- sometimes you have conveyed something but can not make a scene if the same is not being adhered to the invitees -- at least a beginning has been made.
ReplyDeleteAs people see that coming without gifts is a socially acceptable behaviour -- probably it will catch on.
Absolutely a beginning has been made. Without any prejudice towards the host or invitees, the endeavour is to trigger a collective thought process wherein such initiatives ought to be respected by the stakeholders (invitees in this case). While this marriage is over, forthcoming festival season is an apt occasion for a start.
DeleteAbsolutely a beginning has been made. Without any prejudice towards the host or invitees, the endeavour is to trigger a collective thought process wherein such initiatives ought to be respected by the stakeholders (invitees in this case). While this marriage is over, forthcoming festival season is an apt occasion for a start.
ReplyDeleteYour writings reflect how keenly you observe human behaviour. Upon some reflection, I feel that there is certainly a lot of hypocrisy around us. Human beings are complicated individuals whose behaviour is difficult to comprehend. A beautiful line by Walt Whitman says
ReplyDelete"Do I contradict myself? Very well, then I contradict myself, I am large, I contain multitudes"? When we act badly, we are aware of all the rationalizations that would make our bad behavior appear justified. But, the irony is that we don't see these attenuating rationale of others and so the 'others' become hypocrites for us.
So broadly I feel, we have 3 kinds of behaviours - 1) 'our own behaviour ' which we think is right because we tend to justify it always, 2) 'of people whom we like' - again we try and understand their rationale behind their actions and 3) 'of people whom we don't like -The HYPOCRITES '- the people whose wrong actions unnerves us and we find them multi-faceted personalities .
Perhaps, the urge to prove ourselves and try and get an edge over others is what makes us all hypocrites. And this is not at an individual level but this behaviour has insidiously seeped into our collective consciousness of our society.
Regret delayed response. Having an urge to justify the delay but stopping short of it....in light of your remarks about urge to prove ourselves !! I wrote this piece to give a clarion call for the need to bring about the realization that let us all respect the change that surrounds us and shed parochial mindsets - be it with respect to religion or culture or any other domain of our life. Let us all learn to shed boundaries of thought...
Delete